About Bethany

agent photo

Meet Bethany

I
Hi, I’m Bethany. My approach to real estate is simple: building relationships, not just transactions. I’ve spent my career in leadership roles centered on exceptional service, and for more than 25 years I coached teams to put people first. In 2018, I followed my passion for real estate and brought that same dedication, attention to detail, and personalized service to every buyer and seller I work with.
 
Today, I’m known for exceptional branding strategies that showcase listings at their best, strong negotiating skills that protect my clients’ interests, and a high level of personal service that makes each transaction as seamless as possible. Many of my favorite clients come through referrals from friends, family, and past clients — and I have a special affinity for fellow dog lovers.
 
For buyers: Your home should reflect your life and style — a place where you can relax, recharge, and create meaningful moments. I take the time to understand your goals and guide you through the process with clarity and care. Whether you’re buying your first home or your forever home, I’m committed to helping you find a space that truly feels like yours.
 
For sellers: Every home has a unique and compelling story. Through creative, customized marketing and thoughtful branding, I present your property in a way that captures attention and inspires buyers. With meticulous communication and strong negotiation, I represent your best interests with integrity, tenacity, and care to achieve the strongest possible outcome.
 
For commercial clients: From small retail businesses to office spaces, I work closely with you to find a property that supports your vision and reflects your brand. My focus is on understanding your business needs and delivering solutions that position you for long term success.
 
I’m honored to have received industry recognition for both sales excellence and client service, but what matters most to me is the trust my clients place in me. It would be my pleasure to connect, learn about your goals, and support you in your next move.

Bethany Botzenhart

Lic. RE Salesperson
LICENSE NUMBER
10401318474
ADDRESS
5462 Sheridan Dr Williamsville NY 14221

Testimonials

Paulette H.

Paulette H.

Bethany was great to work with. She regularly communicated with us throughout the entire process and kept us informed. I would highly recommend Bethany to anyone selling a home.
Read More
Monica V.

Monica V.

Bethany is the best real estate agent. She took a lot of time to listen to our needs and ideas. She suggested what was best for our family, and because she spent so much time talking to us and getting to know us as a family, sh...
Read More
Jill B.

Jill B.

Bethany is always calm, cool, and collected. She has gone above and beyond in helping me with my recent home purchase, even after I closed. We are now working on selling my existing home and I know I’m in great hands. It is suc...
Read More
Jorge V.

Jorge V.

Bethany provided exceptional assistance in our search for a home in Western NY. Her professionalism, patience, and caring attitude truly set her apart. She not only understood our needs but also made the process seamless. Thank...
Read More
Lucas H.

Lucas H.

Bethany has gone above and beyond for me throughout the entire home-buying process. When a complex requirement from New York State was given to install electric baseboards to get my mortgage, Bethany immediately booked an elect...
Read More
Sarah K.

Sarah K.

It was intimidating to begin the search for a house as a first-time home buyer, but Bethany turned the entire journey into a wonderful and exciting experience. From the beginning, Bethany was always available to answer any ques...
Read More
Mary Lou S.

Mary Lou S.

Bethany is the best! She is so personable and easy to talk with. Knows the business, and responds immediately to any questions. It's her personality that makes you want to work with her. She is a ray of sunshine! So glad to kno...
Read More
Marty S.

Marty S.

Bethany was awesome. Hands-on, and involved in every aspect of listing and selling my nephew's home. I’ve been a Realtor for over 30 years and I can tell you Bethany is a real pro. It takes a lot to impress me and Bethany knock...
Read More
Catherine Y.

Catherine Y.

I met with Bethany shortly after deciding to make my dream of owning my own business a reality. From that first meeting to the ribbon-cutting ceremony, she was there with me every step of the way. She was not only my realtor bu...
Read More
Regina W.

Regina W.

Bethany was wonderful to work with and she was able to find exactly what I needed to relocate my law office. Bethany was readily available to answer any questions and provide knowledgeable guidance every step of the way. I woul...
Read More
Dawn C.

Dawn C.

I can't say enough about Bethany! She helped me find the perfect place for my new office location. She was kind, patient, calm and always smiling. Bethany was there from the first time that I looked at the space, to the countle...
Read More
Gregory R.

Gregory R.

I can't recommend Bethany enough: she was outstanding in communication, direction and advice, professionalism and completely competent. After ~2yrs of searching and many trials, I am now in a home due mostly to her. Also as imp...
Read More
Karina K.

Karina K.

I had the pleasure of working with Bethany for both of my property purchases, and the experience was beyond fantastic each time! Her professionalism, knowledge, and dedication, made the process smooth and stress-free. She truly...
Read More
Brittany B.

Brittany B.

Bethany is not only a great agent, but a great person. She consistently went above and beyond during our home buying process, always communicating kindly and transparently. She does an amazing job at helping you understand ever...
Read More
Cyndi H.

Cyndi H.

Bethany Botzenhart was an outstanding Howard Hanna agent to work with. She is a skilled listener with an in-depth knowledge of the real estate market. She was professional, patient, efficient and effective in selling my brother...
Read More
Elizabeth F.

Elizabeth F.

Bethany is a go getter. She is professional and handles everything in such a wonderful manner. She is hard working and was diligent from start to finish with getting our home sold. She is reliable and always available for any q...
Read More
Kurt G.

Kurt G.

I’ve been involved in two real estate transactions with Bethany in the last three years. Each transaction had significant challenges. Bethany handled these challenges skillfully, while maintaining her professionalism and easy-g...
Read More

Start Your Property Search

Browse Homes

Work With Bethany

Your home should be a reflection of your life and style. A place where you can relax and recharge to make a positive impact on the world again tomorrow. I want to help you find a home that speaks to your passions and pursuits.

Follow Me on Instagram